The best pizza in Montgomery, TX starts with The Pizza Shack on Stewart Creek Road, the most-reviewed pizzeria in the area on Tripadvisor. Crust Pizza Co. near Lake Conroe and Woodforest comes next, followed by familiar chains along Highway 105 West. Montgomery has roughly 3,000 residents and sits about 55 miles northwest of Houston (10 Federal Storage, March 2026), so the list is short. Knowing which spot fits your night matters more than hunting for a hidden gem.
Key Takeaways
- The Pizza Shack, at 19132 Stewart Creek Rd, is the strongest sit-down pick and the most-reviewed pizzeria in Montgomery on Tripadvisor.
- Crust Pizza Co. has two Montgomery-area locations, one near Lake Conroe and one on Woodforest Pkwy N, and is the pick for chewy, firm-crust pizza.
- Papa Johns, Domino’s, Pizza Hut and MOD Pizza all sit on or near Highway 105 West or Eva Street, which makes them practical for delivery and large orders.
- Ratings from Tripadvisor, Slice and Yelp use different scales, so compare review volume and recent comments rather than raw scores.
- Delivery zones vary by store. Enter your exact address on each ordering page before you commit to a group order.
- Groups staying on Lake Conroe can pair a pizza run with a villa that has an outdoor kitchen and game room.
Pizza in Montgomery, TX is a small market in 2026, and that is useful to know before you go. There are a few well-reviewed independents, a pair of Crust Pizza Co. locations, and the national names clustered along Highway 105 West. You will not find twenty competing pizzerias on one block, so choosing well takes about five minutes of planning.
At Nest Awaits, we host groups at The Waterfront Villa on Lake Conroe in Montgomery, TX, so pizza logistics are a regular part of trip planning: who is open late on a Sunday, who will reach a lakeside address, and what feeds a crowd. This guide answers those questions with addresses, hours and review data pulled from public listings.
One caution before the list. Menu items and prices change, and we have not listed a price for any pizza because we cannot verify current menus. Check each restaurant’s own page or app before ordering.
How Is This Ranking of the Best Pizza in Montgomery, TX Built?
This ranking is an ordered shortlist built from published review signals, verified addresses and hours, and how well each spot suits a typical visitor night. It is not a blind taste test, and no single score decides the order. Independents and the Crust Pizza Co. locations rank above chains because their review data and local reputation give you more to go on.
Rating platforms do not use the same scale or audience. Tripadvisor scores restaurants for diners, and Slice scores its own delivery orders. The table below shows each spot’s address and the signal we found, labeled by source. Treat the sources as separate evidence, not a leaderboard.
| Rank | Pizza spot | Address or area | Review signal found | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | The Pizza Shack | 19132 Stewart Creek Rd | 4.4 on 313 Tripadvisor reviews | Sit-down dinners |
| 2nd | Crust Pizza Co. – Lake Conroe | Lake Conroe area | Listed 4.8 out of 5 in business listing data | Chewy crust, lake weekends |
| 3rd | Marini’s Pizza | Listed for Montgomery, TX on Slice | 4.71 out of 5 on 3,667 Slice reviews | Delivery orders |
| 4th | Crust Pizza Co. – Woodforest | 2300 Woodforest Pkwy N, Suite 100 | Customer reviews on Yelp | Woodforest residents and visitors |
| 5th | MOD Pizza | 20175 Eva St., Suite A | Not compared here | Fast, individual pizzas |
| 6th | Papa Johns Pizza | 18442 Highway 105 West, Suite A | Mixed individual reviews | Large takeout orders |
| 7th | Pizza Hut | 15250 Hwy 105 W | Not compared here | Familiar menu for kids |
| 8th | Domino’s | 18446 B Highway 105 W | Not compared here | Late-night orders |
What kinds of pizza restaurants are in Montgomery, TX?
Montgomery pizza falls into four groups: a sit-down independent in The Pizza Shack, Crust Pizza Co. as a multi-location regional operation, a delivery-focused listing in Marini’s Pizza, and national chains along Highway 105 West and Eva Street. If you want a table and a calzone, you have one clear choice. If you want speed or a big box for a group, you have several.
Which Montgomery Pizza Spots Deserve the Top Four Slots?
The top four are the places where a review signal, a distinct identity or both set them apart from a standard chain order. They are The Pizza Shack, both Crust Pizza Co. locations and Marini’s Pizza. Each earns its place for a different reason, so the order shifts depending on whether you want to sit down, drive a short way, or order in.
1. The Pizza Shack: the sit-down pick
The Pizza Shack at 19132 Stewart Creek Rd, Montgomery, TX 77356 holds a 4.4 rating across 313 Tripadvisor reviews, the strongest review volume among Montgomery pizza spots. Its listing describes the menu as pizza, pasta and calzones, so you can feed a table with mixed tastes. If one person in your group does not want pizza, the pasta covers them.
Hours on the Tripadvisor listing run 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Friday and Saturday, and 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM on Sunday. The Sunday close is the one to watch. A 7:30 PM Sunday arrival leaves little margin, so go earlier or call ahead.
A place with 313 reviews draws a crowd on Friday and Saturday evenings. Aim for an early dinner or a weeknight if you want a quiet table. Check the current menu for prices before you go.
2. Crust Pizza Co. at Lake Conroe: the chewy-crust pick
Crust Pizza Co. – Lake Conroe is listed at 4.8 out of 5 in business listing data, and its phone number is (936) 588-0892. One Yelp reviewer describes the crust as firm and chewy. That suits you if you prefer a pizza with some bite over a floppy slice.
This is the location to choose if you are staying near the lake and want an alternative to the chains on Highway 105. Call ahead on weekend evenings, since a small-format pizzeria can back up quickly. Confirm hours and delivery coverage on the official page.
3. Marini’s Pizza: the delivery-app favorite
Marini’s Pizza is listed on Slice’s Montgomery, TX page at 4.71 out of 5 based on 3,667 Slice reviews. That score comes from people who ordered through the app, so it measures delivery satisfaction more than the dining room.
Pick it when you want to order from the couch or the lake house. Slice is the place to confirm its street address, hours and delivery area before you count on it.
4. Crust Pizza Co. at Woodforest: the north-side alternate
The Woodforest location sits at 2300 Woodforest Pkwy N, Suite 100, Montgomery, TX 77316, according to its Yelp listing. It shares the brand with the Lake Conroe store, so the same chewy-crust reputation applies. The Woodlands is approximately 20 to 25 minutes east of Montgomery (10 Federal Storage, March 2026), which makes Woodforest a handy stop for anyone arriving from that direction.
Choose this store if your route comes from the Woodforest side of town. Otherwise the Lake Conroe store is the more natural stop for lake visitors.
Which Pizza Chains Are Worth Ordering From in Montgomery?
Chain pizza in Montgomery, TX means four national names on or near Highway 105 West and Eva Street: MOD Pizza, Papa Johns, Pizza Hut and Domino’s. They rank below the top four because we have less local signal to separate them. Where they win is predictability, long hours and app-based tracking, which count for a lot when you are feeding a crowd late on a travel day.
5. MOD Pizza: fast individual pizzas
MOD Pizza is at 20175 Eva St., Suite A, Montgomery, TX 77356. Its counter model is built around individual pizzas that you customize as you move down the line. That suits groups where everyone wants something different, including a vegetarian or a picky kid. The line is typically shortest outside the noon and early-evening rushes.
6. Papa Johns Pizza: the big-order option
Papa Johns is at 18442 Highway 105 West, Suite A, Montgomery, TX 77356. It works best for bulk takeout, where a few large pizzas and sides cover a table. Individual customer reviews are mixed, and one reviewer called a pizza thin and soggy, so read recent comments and check that your order is hot before you leave the lot.
7. Pizza Hut: the familiar menu for kids
Pizza Hut’s Montgomery location is listed at 15250 Hwy 105 W. It earns a slot for families who want a menu children already recognize. Confirm current hours and delivery on the brand’s store locator.
8. Domino’s: the late-night fallback
Domino’s is at 18446 B Highway 105 W, Montgomery, TX 77356, next door to Papa Johns. Search listings show Monday and Wednesday hours of 10:30 AM to 12:00 AM, the longest window we found for any pizza spot on this list. For a post-lake arrival after 9:00 PM, this is likely your most reliable option.
Which Montgomery Pizza Places Deliver to Your Address?
Pizza delivery in Montgomery, TX depends on each store’s delivery zone, not on the town you type into a search box. Lake-area addresses, new subdivisions and rural roads can fall outside a zone even when the restaurant is a few miles away. Because we cannot verify any store’s zone, the only reliable method is to enter your exact street address on the official ordering page.
Use this order of operations when you are planning a delivery night:
- Enter the full address on the Domino’s, Papa Johns or Pizza Hut app and see which stores accept it.
- Search the address on Slice to see whether Marini’s Pizza and other independents deliver there.
- Call Crust Pizza Co. directly, since its Lake Conroe store lists a phone number, and ask about delivery or carryout times.
- If everything declines, plan a carryout run with The Pizza Shack, and call ahead to confirm timing.
If you are staying at a lakeside rental, do this before you arrive, not at 7:00 PM on a Saturday. A hungry guest who finds the zone closed has a short list of options.
What Pizza Styles Can You Get in Montgomery, TX?
Pizza styles in Montgomery, TX are mostly American-style rounds: hand-tossed or pan pizzas from the chains, firm and chewy crust from Crust Pizza Co., and pizza with calzones and pasta from The Pizza Shack. You will not find a Neapolitan oven or a deep-dish specialist in our research. If you want a specific regional style, look in Houston, about 55 miles away (10 Federal Storage, March 2026).
For a practical match, pick by crust and format:
- Chewy, firm crust: Crust Pizza Co., per a Yelp reviewer’s description.
- Calzones and baked pasta: The Pizza Shack, based on its menu categories.
- Build-your-own individual pies: MOD Pizza.
- Large, familiar delivery pies: Papa Johns, Domino’s and Pizza Hut.
How Do You Order Pizza for a Big Group at Lake Conroe?
Ordering pizza for a large group means splitting the order across two sources so nothing arrives late or cold. The Waterfront Villa sleeps up to 15 guests across 5 bedrooms, so a standard weekend dinner for the full house is a big order. Lake Conroe is a 21,000-acre reservoir (10 Federal Storage, March 2026), and many visitors spend the day on the water and the evening hungry.
A workable plan: place one large delivery order from a chain that accepts the villa’s address, and pick up a second order from The Pizza Shack or Crust Pizza Co. for variety. Appetites after a boating day vary, so order slightly more than you think you need and let leftovers become next-day lunch.
The villa’s game room and pool table give kids and adults something to do while you wait. The outdoor kitchen and BBQ grill let you pair pizza with grilled sides rather than ordering everything by the box. The full kitchen handles reheating leftovers.
What Do Pizza Ratings Across Platforms Actually Tell You?
Pizza ratings across Tripadvisor, Slice and Yelp measure different things, so they cannot be ranked against each other. Tripadvisor reflects diners and visitors, while Slice reflects customers who ordered through its delivery app. A 4.71 on Slice and a 4.4 on Tripadvisor are not the same measurement.
Use ratings in three steps. First, look at review volume: 313 reviews on a restaurant says more than a perfect score on a handful. Second, read the most recent comments for crust, wait time and temperature on arrival. Third, check whether the platform even covers dine-in. A delivery-heavy rating tells you how the box arrived, not how the room feels.
One individual review, such as a complaint about a soggy crust, is not a consensus. It is a reason to look at several recent comments before deciding. A high score from one app is a reason to try the restaurant, not proof that it beats every other option.
What Are Common Mistakes When Choosing Pizza in Montgomery?
The most common mistakes are assuming delivery will reach your address, trusting one rating source, and arriving after closing. Montgomery’s pizza hours are shorter than a big-city market, and the Sunday close at The Pizza Shack is the clearest example. A bit of planning avoids a cold dinner of gas-station snacks.
- Skipping the address check. Enter your exact address on each ordering page before you plan around delivery.
- Arriving late on Sunday. The Pizza Shack’s listed Sunday hours end at 8:00 PM.
- Comparing scores across apps. Slice, Tripadvisor and Yelp are separate systems.
- Ordering at peak time. Friday and Saturday evenings between 6:00 PM and 8:00 PM are the likeliest windows for long waits. Order early or call ahead.
- Skipping the phone call. Hours and delivery zones change, and a two-minute call beats a 20-minute drive to a closed door.
While you are in town, the Montgomery, Texas tourism page and our guide to the best restaurants in Montgomery, TX cover options beyond pizza for the other nights of your trip.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza in Montgomery, TX?
The Pizza Shack at 19132 Stewart Creek Rd is the strongest all-around pick, based on its review volume on Tripadvisor and its sit-down menu of pizza, pasta and calzones. Crust Pizza Co. at Lake Conroe is the best alternate for firm, chewy crust. Marini’s Pizza leads on Slice for delivery.
What are The Pizza Shack’s hours in Montgomery?
The Tripadvisor listing shows 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday, 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM on Sunday. Call ahead for holiday hours, since listings can lag behind real changes.
Which Montgomery pizza places deliver to my address?
It depends on each store’s delivery zone. Enter your full address on the Papa Johns, Domino’s or Pizza Hut ordering pages, and search it on Slice for Marini’s Pizza and other independents. For Crust Pizza Co., call the Lake Conroe store to ask about delivery or carryout.
Which pizza place is closest to Woodforest?
Crust Pizza Co. at 2300 Woodforest Pkwy N, Suite 100, Montgomery, TX 77316 is the Woodforest location. It carries the same brand as the Lake Conroe store, so the same crust reputation applies. Confirm hours on the brand’s page.
Are there locally owned pizza restaurants in Montgomery, TX?
The Pizza Shack is the clearest independent name in our research, and Crust Pizza Co. operates two Montgomery-area stores. Papa Johns, Domino’s, Pizza Hut and MOD Pizza are national brands. Check each restaurant’s own site to confirm ownership.
What is the best place to stay in Montgomery, TX for a group pizza weekend?
Nest Awaits offers The Waterfront Villa, a 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath lakefront home on Lake Conroe that sleeps up to 15 guests and includes a full kitchen, outdoor kitchen, BBQ grill and game room. Compare any rental by sleeping layout, kitchen size and whether the address falls inside local delivery zones.
Where Does the Best Pizza in Montgomery, TX Leave You?
The best pizza in Montgomery, TX comes down to a clear order: The Pizza Shack for a sit-down meal, Crust Pizza Co. for chewy crust near the lake, Marini’s Pizza for app-based delivery, and the Highway 105 chains for speed and volume. Review scores are directional, hours are tight on Sundays, and delivery zones decide whether the pie arrives at your door.
Before you travel in 2026, verify hours and zones with a quick call or an address check. Groups planning a lake weekend do best by splitting orders, planning early dinners and keeping Domino’s on the list as a late-night fallback.
If your plan is a lake weekend with a pizza night built in, The Waterfront Villa puts a full kitchen and an outdoor grill under one roof, so you can mix takeout with home cooking. Check availability at The Waterfront Villa, or see our guide to Montgomery vacation rentals on Lake Conroe to compare your options.
Content powered by inkSTR.co